Quantcast
CultureMass
  • Home
  • Impact
  • Are You Entertained?
  • Life Unfiltered
  • Opinion
  • Best Of the Net
No Result
View All Result
CultureMass

In New York, Intolerance Has Become Routine

Some 38 percent of those surveyed said they had been verbally harassed or taunted because of their race or faith.

Rahima Nasa, ProPublica by Rahima Nasa, ProPublica
|
September 25, 2018
in Impact
In New York, Intolerance Has Become Routine

Lower East Side (credit: Greyframe)

79
SHARES
168
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

It is just a snapshot, but it makes for a plenty ugly picture all the same: The New York City Commission on Human Rights surveyed more than 3,000 Muslim, Jewish and Sikh residents of the city late in 2017 and found striking rates of racially and or religiously motivated assault, harassment and workplace discrimination.

Some 38 percent of those surveyed said they had been verbally harassed or taunted because of their race or faith. Nearly 10 percent said they had been the victim of an actual physical assault. A similar percentage of those surveyed said they had seen their property vandalized or otherwise defaced.

Lurking in those broad numbers are some more specific outrages: 18 percent of Sikhs surveyed said they had been denied service by a local business; roughly 6 percent of those surveyed who said they wore religious garments reported having had someone try and tear those garments off them.

The commission, which enforces the city’s anti-discrimination statute governing employment, housing and public accommodation, said last month’s “first of its kind” report was meant to “rigorously document” experiences of bias harassment, discrimination and acts of hate. They survey was conducted in the late fall of 2017, and asked respondents to report incidents dating back to mid-2016, the height of a volatile election season.

New York City Commission on Human Rights

Some 17 percent of those surveyed reported some form of discrimination at work — from being told they could not observe their faith to being told they could not wear religious clothing. Roughly 3 percent reported being fired because of their race, ethnicity or religion.

The findings are consistent with national and local trends. The FBI and the New York City Police Department have seen increases in reports of hate crimes in the last several years. A recent report from the California attorney general’s office showed that hate crimes in the state have increased by about 17 percent in the last year and have been on the rise for the last three years.

Yet the commission’s survey underscored a stubborn fact about bias-driven harassment and crimes: People by and large opt not to report them. Fewer than one in three people who said in the survey that they had been verbally harassed or physically assaulted said they reported it to anybody — whether that be the police, a local advocacy group or religious leaders in their communities. And while Sikhs reported distinctively high rates of abuse — Sikhs under 35 were nearly twice as likely to experience verbal harassment as others surveyed, for instance — they were the least likely to report these experiences.

Ramatu Ahmed, executive director of the Bronx-based African Life Center, a community organization that assists immigrants with social services, noted that the low rates of reporting incidents reflects a general apprehension about contacting police, a reluctance often shaped by people’s interactions with police in their home countries.

“Back in my culture, you don’t do much with the police,” said Ahmed, who is an immigrant from Ghana. “You do everything to not associate yourself with the police and a lot of people bring that mentality when they come here.”

The commission offered some breakdowns of those it surveyed — 50 percent were Muslim; 31 percent were Jewish; 6 percent were as young as 16 or 17 and 10 percent were over 65 — but also said that in its public report no numbers or percentages were cited unless they had been deemed statistically significant.

The population perhaps most at risk? Black Muslim women in the Bronx, where one in five reported being physically assaulted in the months in question.

Carmelyn P. Malalis, the city human right commissioner, said one of the things that struck her in the survey was how many of those reporting abuse “have accepted these indignities as part of their everyday lives.”

“Sadly, the high rates of bias and discrimination revealed in this survey were not surprising given the recent wave of xenophobic and Islamophobic rhetoric surrounding changes in federal immigration policies and bias-motivated attacks and harassment against these communities,” said Malalis.

 

Tags: ANTI-SEMITISMcommentaryDISCRIMINATIONISLAMOPHOBIANew YorkNew York City Commission on Human RightsXENOPHOBIA
Previous Post

We've Seen This Before: Art As Warning

Next Post

How Traveling Can Help In The Pursued of Your Passions

Rahima Nasa, ProPublica

Rahima Nasa, ProPublica

Rahima Nasa is a reporting fellow for ProPublica’s Documenting Hate project. A journalist who covers crime, courts and politics, she has worked for The New York Daily News and “The Brian Lehrer Show” on WNYC, among others. She graduated from the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism and is a Bangladesh-born native New Yorker.

Next Post
How Traveling Can Help In The Pursued of Your Passions

How Traveling Can Help In The Pursued of Your Passions

Discussion about this post

Recommended.

What does school look and sound like when you and your classmates are deaf?

What does school look and sound like when you and your classmates are deaf?

September 27, 2018
How Indirect Violence Gets Under a Child’s Skin — and Into the Brain

How Indirect Violence Gets Under a Child’s Skin — and Into the Brain

September 25, 2018
ADVERTISEMENT

Trending.

Is the New ‘Mulan’ A Girl Worth Fighting For?

Is the New ‘Mulan’ A Girl Worth Fighting For?

September 11, 2020
Marines Move to Tackle Racial Extremists in the Corps

Marines Move to Tackle Racial Extremists in the Corps

October 1, 2018
Inside Meghan Duggan and Gillian Apps Storybook Love

Inside Meghan Duggan and Gillian Apps Storybook Love

September 27, 2018
Knives Out Kills With Kindness

Knives Out Kills With Kindness

August 20, 2020
Malea Tjandrawidjaja Stole The Show And Our Hearts

Malea Tjandrawidjaja Stole The Show And Our Hearts

September 27, 2018

From Our Partner

CultureMass

We are independent thinkers fueled by the different cultures we encounter and the conversations of the people that inspire us.

CultureMass is part of CultureMass Media, LLC. © 2020 All rights reserved.

AdChoices
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • Send us a tip
  • Contact Us
  • AdChoices

Follow Us

Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube

Newsletter

Enter your email to receive our official newsletter. The newsletter is completely free, we won’t send spam, we won’t share your personal information, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Impact
  • Are You Entertained?
  • Life Unfiltered
  • Opinion
  • Best Of the Net

© 2020 CultureMass is part of CultureMass Media, LLC. All rights reserved.

  • Login
  • Register
Lost Your password?
You don't have permission to register
LOGIN